Advertisement

Call for change as Leaving Certificate exams branded 'a trend of the past'

A former teacher says the Leaving Certificate is "a trend of the past" and should be re-thought i...
Jack Quann
Jack Quann

11.02 24 May 2020


Share this article


Call for change as Leaving Cer...

Call for change as Leaving Certificate exams branded 'a trend of the past'

Jack Quann
Jack Quann

11.02 24 May 2020


Share this article


A former teacher says the Leaving Certificate is "a trend of the past" and should be re-thought in future.

The exams have been cancelled for 2020 in light of the coronavirus pandemic.

Students will instead be given 'calculated grades' in its place.

Advertisement

Those who do not wish to accept the calculated grades will be able to sit the exams at a later date.

The process for calculating grades will involve teachers, school principals and a new unit within the Department of Education.

Dr Aoibhinn Ni Shuilleabhain, assistant professor at UCD’s School of Mathematics and Science, told Newstalk Breakfast with Susan Keogh there are inherent biases built into the system.

"It is a comprehensive process, it's not ideal - but it's the best I think we can do with the situation right now.

"I really think we should take this opportunity to re-think: if this were to happen again, how could we prepare better for it?

"Really should we be re-thinking our one exam system for our Leaving Cert students."

"I think one reason people want to hold on to our Leaving Cert system is the view that it's quite independent and it's extremely fair.

"While it is great that it's anonymous... there are a lot of inherent biases actually built into the system and we have to consider that.

"It's not the best system for all of our students.

"Students who are from economic disadvantaged areas - for example the DEIS schools... they're far less likely to do as well in the CAO system.

"And that is absolutely nothing to do with their ability, but likely to do with their environment that they find themselves in - but also the opportunities that their schools offer.

"There are DEIS schools that don't offer honours Irish [or] honours maths - and that takes you out of a lot of those points that there is a race for".

She said the issue of the cost of grinds and gender representation in specific subjects - such as the 3:1 radio of boys to girls taking physics - are also affecting the system.

Dr Ni Shuillebhan said: "If we starting looking under the hood a little bit, the CAO system, the Leaving Cert system, isn't as fair as we might think.

"And if we look at international trends and what other countries do around the world very, very few of them depend on one 100% exam.

"It's a trend of the past that we've happened to continue in Ireland with our industrial age education system.

"But we're not in that age anymore and we need to re-think what do we want our students coming out of secondary level school with?"

Main image: 2013 Leaving Certificate exams start at O'Connells School in Dublin. Picture by: Sam Boal/Photocall Ireland

Share this article


Read more about

2020 Leaving Cert Bias CAO Dr Aoibhinn Ni Shuilleabhain Leaving Cert Newstalk Breakast Rethink

Most Popular